« Taking it personal(ized) | Main | Good Golly Ms. Holly! »
September 07, 2006
Survey Says: Innovative Healthcare Solutions and Politics Don’t Mix
by Holly Heline Jarrell
Decade after decade, in poll after poll, the public beseeches Congress and the President to focus their attention on a broken healthcare system. In a recent Harris Interactive survey on behalf of The Commonwealth Fund, an overwhelming majority calls for “fundamental changes” to – or a “complete rebuild” of – the system. See link: http://www.cmwf.org/surveys/surveys_show.htm?doc_id=394593 (You’ll find like sentiments echoed in plenty of free-standing polls as well.) Whether innovation comes in the form of better coordinated care, computerized health records or new thinking on how to ensure the solvency of Medicare (majorities support all of these), Americans see healthcare policy change as “job one” for Congress (or “two” depending on the pollster). This is not new.
But there is new evidence that the public shouldn’t hold its collective breath waiting for out-of-the-box health policy thinking at the Congressional level. For its voter guide, AARP recently conducted a survey among Congressional candidates on issues including Medicare and insurance plans. Forget the tabulated results, the real story is found in the thoughtfulness of the respondents: To answer the survey, candidates in Georgia, Illinois, Iowa, South Carolina, and Texas simply copied – word for word in some cases – party-line sound bites originating from the National Republican Congressional Committee. (As a survey professional, I find this an appalling way to deal with an “open-ended” question – it defeats the purpose!)
Democrats blast the GOP candidates saying the “plagiarized” survey results suggest “more of the same.” See link: http://www.forbes.com/technology/ebusiness/feeds/ap/2006/08/31/ap2986766.html
The story really isn’t all that political, though. It could happen on either side of the fence. Rather, the lack of original thinking – or thinking at all – makes one simply question the possibility of creative healthcare solutions, open dialogue, and – dare we say, innovation – from the Hill.
Posted by holly_heline_jarrell at September 7, 2006 04:09 PM
Trackback Pings
TrackBack URL for this entry:
/cgi-bin/mt-tb.cgi/23

